Freedom of the Seas

Royal Caribbean International · CDC Vessel Sanitation Program record

Satisfactory: score 94 out of 100

Latest inspection August 8, 2026 · CDC inspection report

CDC’s passing mark is 86 out of 100.

Cruise line
Royal Caribbean International
Inspections in this snapshot
33
Currently on the Green Sheet
Yes

Score history

Dates and scores are as CDC's inspection search returned them. Failing scores are shaded. Each report link goes to the official CDC page.

Score history for Freedom of the Seas

Inspection dateScore and official resultCDC report
August 8, 202694 SatisfactoryOfficial report
February 12, 202694 SatisfactoryOfficial report
September 6, 202598 SatisfactoryOfficial report
March 15, 202594 SatisfactoryOfficial report
October 27, 202395 SatisfactoryOfficial report
February 6, 202394 SatisfactoryOfficial report
June 9, 201997 SatisfactoryOfficial report
December 23, 201891 SatisfactoryOfficial report
July 28, 201898 SatisfactoryOfficial report
January 14, 201896 SatisfactoryOfficial report
April 9, 201786 SatisfactoryOfficial report
January 29, 2017100 SatisfactoryOfficial report
February 7, 2016100 SatisfactoryOfficial report
August 23, 201598 SatisfactoryOfficial report
November 23, 201486 SatisfactoryOfficial report
April 6, 2014100 SatisfactoryOfficial report
November 20, 201399 SatisfactoryOfficial report
August 25, 201397 SatisfactoryOfficial report
February 17, 201396 SatisfactoryOfficial report
April 22, 201296 SatisfactoryOfficial report
December 30, 201199 SatisfactoryOfficial report
June 19, 201197 SatisfactoryOfficial report
January 16, 2011100 SatisfactoryOfficial report
August 8, 201099 SatisfactoryOfficial report
February 21, 201097 SatisfactoryOfficial report
July 26, 200999 SatisfactoryOfficial report
February 1, 200999 SatisfactoryOfficial report
August 24, 2008100 SatisfactoryOfficial report
January 6, 200895 SatisfactoryOfficial report
July 29, 200795 SatisfactoryOfficial report
February 25, 200797 SatisfactoryOfficial report
September 10, 200697 SatisfactoryOfficial report
June 18, 200695 SatisfactoryOfficial report

Latest official findings

The official report lists the following findings. The wording is quoted from CDC, grouped by the area of the ship so it is easier to read. We do not change the inspector's wording.

Drinking water (3 findings)

Item 08

Where it was found: Potable Water-Bunkering Potable Water Hoses

Official finding: Two potable water bunkering hoses actively being used to bunker water during the inspection were frayed in several areas causing water to drip onto the deck inside the bunker station.

Official recommendation

Construct all hoses, fittings, and water filters used in the bunkering of potable water of safe, easy-to-clean materials approved for potable water use and maintain them in good repair.

Item 08

Where it was found: Potable Water-Cross-Connection Log - Pump Room #2 Starboard Side

Official finding: The forward high-pressure washing unit’s reduced pressure zone (RPZ) assembly was reportedly replaced on 17 July 2025; however, it had not been inspected since the replacement, exceeding the required annual testing interval. The crew was unable to locate records documenting the RPZ replacement or identifying the date of its most recent inspection.

Official recommendation

Inspect and test backflow prevention devices requiring testing (for example, reduced pressure backflow prevention devices and pressure vacuum breakers) with a test kit after installation and at least annually. Maintain test results showing the pressure differences on both sides of the valves for each device. Retain the visual inspection and/or test results for backflow prevention devices and air gaps for at least 12 months and ensure they are available for review during inspections.

Item 07

Where it was found: Potable Water-Cross-Connection Log - Pump Room #2 Starboard Side

Official finding: The forward high-pressure washing unit was noted to be replaced on 17 July 2025 which exceeded the required annual testing time frame for backflow prevention devices. Crew were unable to find any record for the replacement of this RPZ in the work order system. Additionally, no entry was recorded for this device on the potable water disinfection log. Additionally, no entry was recorded for this assembly on the potable water disinfection log.

Official recommendation

Disinfect the potable water system after potential contamination by increasing the free halogen residual to at least 50 mg/L (ppm) throughout the affected area and maintain this concentration for 4 hours or by way of another procedure submitted to and accepted by VSP.

Galleys and dining rooms (27 findings)

Item 27

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 3 - Blast Chiller

Official finding: The drain line did not properly extend to the deck scupper and water leaked onto the deck. The outside of the drain line was excessively soiled with black and pink mold like film. Crew initiated corrective action immediately.

Official recommendation

Ensure nonfood-contact surfaces of equipment are kept free of an accumulation of dust, dirt, food residue, and other debris.

Item 20

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 11 - Chops Grille

Official finding: Water dripped from the combination oven down the front of the undercounter refrigeration unit and onto the deck below.

Official recommendation

Maintain food-contact equipment in good repair and proper adjustment: (1) Equipment must be maintained in a state of repair and condition that meets the materials, design, construction, and operation specifications of these standards.

Item 21

Where it was found: Food Service General-Sealant in Disrepair

Official finding: Sealant was missing or in disrepair in the following areas:

  • Deck 14
  • Suite Lounge, front of buffet countertop
  • Deck 12
  • Johnny Rockets, dining area beverage station
  • Deck 11
  • El Loco Fresh, condiment bar
  • Deck 11
  • El Loco Fresh, around the countertop on the service side (underneath the tacos sign)
  • Deck 11
  • Windjammer, Jade Line, portside next to the cold well
  • Deck 11
  • Windjammer, Fresh from the Garden, carving station
  • Deck 11
  • Windjammer, International Flavors, all countertops These were immediately corrected.
Official recommendation

Design and construct nonfood-contact surfaces of equipment and utensils to be durable and to retain their characteristic qualities under normal use conditions. Ensure nonfood-contact surfaces are free of unnecessary ledges, projections, and crevices, and are designed and constructed to allow easy cleaning and to facilitate maintenance.

Item 33

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 11 - Chops Grille

Official finding: Water dripped from the combination oven down the front of the undercounter refrigeration unit and onto the deck below.

Official recommendation

Ensure decks, bulkheads, and deckheads in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, bars, and food and equipment storage areas are constructed and maintained for easy cleaning. Ensure decks, bulkheads, deckheads, and attached equipment in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, and storage areas are cleaned as often as necessary.

Item 20

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 4 - Boleros

Official finding: A slotted fastener was on the food splash zone of two soda gun dispensers.

Official recommendation

Use low profile, nonslotted, noncorroding, and easy-to-clean fasteners on food-contact surfaces and in splash zones. Prohibit the use of exposed slotted screws, Phillips head screws, or pop rivets in these areas.

Item 33

Where it was found: Dining Room-Deck 11 - El Loco Fresh - Condiment Bar

Official finding: The black coving along the bulkhead/deck was in disrepair throughout this area.

Official recommendation

Cove all bulkhead/deck, equipment/deck, cabinet/deck, counter/bulkhead/backsplash, and deck sink coaming/deck junctures in galleys, pantries, buffets, bars, waiter stations, dining room work counters, provisions, scrapping stations, food storage rooms, food transportation corridors, equipment or utensil storage rooms, and toilet rooms intended for use by food employees.

Item 08

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 5 - Beverage Station

Official finding: Biofilm and water collected in the continuous pressure backflow prevention device atmospheric vent which was angled slightly upward. Crew initiated corrective action immediately.

Official recommendation

Maintain backflow prevention devices in good repair.

Item 20

Where it was found: Galley-Decks 3 and 4 Hot Lines

Official finding: Eight heating lamps on each deck were excessively rusted and in disrepair. At least three were damaged with significant dents and sharp cracks which were difficult to clean and a risk to food worker safety. The rusted, thin, metal strips directly above the heating elements were separating from the larger lamp housing. The fasteners for these strips were rusted and some of the strips were not properly attached. One strip was no longer attached and was laying on the protective metal grid below. No food was out for service under any of the units during the inspection.

Official recommendation

Maintain food-contact equipment in good repair and proper adjustment: (1) Equipment must be maintained in a state of repair and condition that meets the materials, design, construction, and operation specifications of these standards.

Item 34

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 3 - Blast Chiller

Official finding: The drain line did not properly extend to the deck scupper and leaked on the deck. The outside of the drain line was excessively soiled with black and pink mold like film. Crew initiated corrective action immediately.

Official recommendation

Ensure the plumbing system in food areas is in good repair.

Item 35

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 3 - Blast Chiller

Official finding: The drain line did not properly extend to the deck scupper and water leaked onto the deck. Crew initiated corrective action immediately.

Official recommendation

Ensure black and gray water is discharged to the vessel's wastewater disposal system and does not pool on the deck.

Item 27

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 3 - Beverage Station Counter #1

Official finding: A small amount of black debris was behind the far back lip in the 'not for consumption' counter-recessed ice bin. The area was difficult to access and difficult to clean.

Official recommendation

Ensure nonfood-contact surfaces of equipment are kept free of an accumulation of dust, dirt, food residue, and other debris.

Item 21

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 3 - Beverage Station Counter #1

Official finding: The far back lip in the 'not for consumption' counter recessed ice bin was difficult to access and difficult to clean. This area was soiled with a small amount of black debris.

Official recommendation

Ensure equipment that is fixed because it is not easily movable is installed in one of the following ways: (1) Spaced to allow access for cleaning along the sides, behind, under and above the equipment; (2) Spaced from adjoining equipment, bulkhead, and deckhead at a distance of no more than 0.8 millimeters or 1/32 inch; (3) Sealed to adjoining equipment or bulkhead. Ensure nonfood-contact surfaces are free of unnecessary ledges, projections, and crevices, and are designed and constructed to allow easy cleaning and to facilitate maintenance.

Item 08

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 3 - Vegetable Station

Official finding: The continuous pressure backflow prevention device's atmospheric vent was facing upwards. Crew initiated corrective action immediately.

Official recommendation

Maintain backflow prevention devices in good repair.

Item 33

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 3 - Sauce Station

Official finding: Three deck tiles were damaged with holes leading to open space under the tiles. Crew indicated these tiles were on a list for repair.

Official recommendation

Ensure decks, bulkheads, and deckheads in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, bars, and food and equipment storage areas are constructed and maintained for easy cleaning. Ensure decks, bulkheads, and deckheads in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, and storage areas are maintained in good repair.

Item 20

Where it was found: Buffet-Deck 3 - Crew Mess

Official finding: The bulk milk dispensing tube protruded 1.25-1.75 inches below the refrigeration compartment. Crew immediately corrected the issue.

Official recommendation

Cut bulk milk dispensing tubes on the diagonal, leaving no more than 25 millimeters (1 inch) protruding from the chilled dispensing head.

Item 33

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 3 - Walk-In Freezer

Official finding: Excessive ice accumulated in two deckhead light fixtures. In one fixture, ice filled half of the area within the protective plastic shield. Crew immediately initiated corrective action.

Official recommendation

Ensure decks, bulkheads, deckheads, and attached equipment in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, and storage areas are cleaned as often as necessary.

Item 22

Where it was found: Galley-Deck 3

Official finding: Small particles of debris floated inside of the 55-gallon sanitizing solution bucket. The solution was changed.

Official recommendation

Ensure the sanitize solution is kept clean.

Item 34

Where it was found: Preparation Room-Deck 2

Official finding: Potable water dripped from the potato machine fill line and excessive water collected on the deck.

Official recommendation

Ensure the plumbing system in food areas is in good repair.

Item 33

Where it was found: Preparation Room-Deck 2

Official finding: Water pooled on the deck from the potato peeler’s potable water filling line.

Official recommendation

Ensure decks, bulkheads, deckheads, and attached equipment in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, and storage areas are cleaned as often as necessary.

Item 38

Where it was found: Preparation Room-Deck 2

Official finding: Crew reported that the pulper is not used for current operations, is not needed for current operations, and were unsure of when the unit was last used.

Official recommendation

Ensure only articles necessary for the operation of food service areas are stored in food preparation, food storage, and warewashing areas.

Item 27

Where it was found: Preparation Room-Deck 2

Official finding: The pulper unit was full of soiled water. Crew explained that whenever the ship pulper system is operating, water will flow into the unit, and subsequently, the technical crew must flush the system.

Official recommendation

Ensure nonfood-contact surfaces of equipment are kept free of an accumulation of dust, dirt, food residue, and other debris.

Item 37

Where it was found: Provisions-Deck 0 - Egg Box

Official finding: Excessive condensate collected on the deckhead and dripped onto the deck below.

Official recommendation

Ensure heating, ventilating, and air conditioning systems are designed and installed so that make-up air intake and exhaust vents do not cause contamination of food, food-contact surfaces, equipment, or utensils.

Item 33

Where it was found: Provisions-Deck 0 - Egg Box

Official finding: Excessive condensate collected on the deckhead and dripped onto the deck below.

Official recommendation

Ensure decks, bulkheads, deckheads, and attached equipment in food preparation, warewashing, pantries, and storage areas are cleaned as often as necessary.

Item 40

Where it was found: Dining Room-Deck 11 - Windjammer

Official finding: Pest management crew have been treating the same two locations (bench seating and starboard island buffet) with recurring pest findings for over one month. Pest management logs noted finding of 10 13 live cockroaches during several follow up inspections. No cockroaches were documented or reported to be found in the traps. Pest management crew have used the pesticides that are approved for them to use. Crew reported that recently, technical crew have begun being involved in improving the areas, such as by painting the deck under bench seats. In the buffet island undercounter sink technical space, some small seams were noted. No live insects were observed by the inspectors during the inspection.

Official recommendation

Protect entry points where pests may enter the food areas.

Item 21

Where it was found: Buffet-Windjammer

Official finding: In the starboard side buffet island undercounter sink technical space, some small seams were noted.

Official recommendation

Ensure nonfood-contact surfaces are free of unnecessary ledges, projections, and crevices, and are designed and constructed to allow easy cleaning and to facilitate maintenance.

Item 16

Where it was found: Provisions-Deck 1 - Dairy

Official finding: The internal temperatures of several time/temperature control for safety (TCS) / potentially hazardous food (PHF) items loaded on the day of inspection were measured in the temperature danger zone by both the inspector and crew with calibrated, tip-sensitive thermometers: 1) Five 5-pound containers of sour cream measured 50-60°F. There were approximately 60 containers. 2) Three 32-ounce logs of mozzarella cheese measured 46-58°F. There were 36 logs. 3) Two 5- pound containers of cottage cheese measured 58°F. There were approximately 8 containers.4) One half-gallon jug of milk measured 46°F. There were several jugs.5) One half-pint of milk measured 44°F. There were several cartons.Crew initially indicated the items were loaded approximately 1.5 hours prior to the inspection finding. Later, when a crew member was presenting logs of the food temperature readings upon receipt of food, the crew member indicated the food was loaded approximately 2.5 hours prior to the inspection. Crew explained temperatures are initially measured when the food is still on the refrigerated truck, is offloaded from the truck, and rapidly loaded onto the vessel, leaving the food outside on the dock for approximately 5 minutes. Crew initiated corrective action either discarding or cooling the food, as appropriate.

Official recommendation

Except during preparation, cooking, or cooling, or when time is used as the public health control, maintain TCS/PHF at 57°C (135°F) or above, except that roasts may be held at a temperature of 54°C (130°F); or 5°C (41°F) or less. Maintain shell eggs that have not been treated to destroy all viable Salmonella spp. are maintained at 7°C (45°F) or less.

Item 13

Where it was found: Provisions-Deck 1 - Dairy

Official finding: The internal temperatures of several time/temperature control for safety (TCS) / potentially hazardous food (PHF) items loaded on the day of inspection were measured in the temperature danger zone by both the inspector and crew with calibrated, tip-sensitive thermometers: 1) Five 5-pound containers of sour cream measured 50-60°F. There were approximately 60 containers. 2) Three 32-ounce logs of mozzarella cheese measured 46-58°F. There were 36 logs. 3) Two 5- pound containers of cottage cheese measured 58°F. There were approximately 8 containers. 4) One half-gallon jug of milk measured 46°F. There were several jugs. 5) One half-pint of milk measured 44°F. There were several cartons. Crew initially indicated the items were loaded approximately 1.5 hours prior to the inspection finding. Later, when a crew member was presenting logs of the food temperature readings upon receipt of food, the crew member indicated the food was loaded approximately 2.5 hours prior to the inspection. Crew explained temperatures are initially measured when the food is still on the refrigerated truck, is offloaded from the truck, and rapidly loaded onto the vessel, leaving the food outside on the dock for approximately 5 minutes. Crew were not monitoring cooling at the time of inspection. Crew initiated corrective action either discarding or cooling the food, as appropriate.

Official recommendation

Ensure the supervisor or person in charge of food operations on the vessel monitors that: (1) Food operations are not conducted in a room used as living or sleeping quarters; (2) Persons unnecessary to the food operation are not allowed in the food areas; (3) Employees and other persons such as delivery and maintenance persons and pesticide applicators entering the food preparation, food storage, or warewashing areas comply with these standards; (4) Food employees are effectively cleaning their hands; (5) Employees are observing food as they are received to determine that they are from approved sources, delivered at the required temperatures, protected from contamination, unadulterated, and accurately presented; (6) Employees are properly cooking TCS/PHF, being particularly careful in cooking food known to cause severe foodborne illness and death, such as eggs and comminuted meats; (7) Employees are using proper methods to rapidly cool TCS/PHF that is not held hot or are not for consumption within 4 hours; (8) Consumers who order raw or partially cooked ready-to-eat food of animal origin are informed that the food is not cooked sufficiently to ensure its safety; (9) Employees are properly sanitizing cleaned multiuse equipment and utensils before they are reused; (10) Consumers are notified that clean tableware is to be used when they return to self-service areas such as salad bars and buffets; (11) Employees are preventing cross-contamination of ready-to-eat food with bare hands by properly using suitable utensils such as deli tissue, spatulas, tongs, single-use gloves, or dispensing equipment; (12) Employees are properly trained in food safety, including food allergy awareness, as it relates to their assigned duties; (13) Food employees are informed of their responsibility to report to the supervisor or person in charge information about their health and activities as they relate to diseases transmissible through food.

Housekeeping (1 finding)

Item 41

Where it was found: Housekeeping-Acute Gastroenteritis (AGE) Cabin Cleaning Log

Official finding: No AGE cabin cleaning record was documented for stateroom #1359 regarding a passenger with reported AGE symptoms on 22 April 2026 and a release from medical isolation on 23 April 2026. Crew were only able to provide documentation for the soiled linens being dropped off in the laundry room during that time frame.

Official recommendation

Ensure cabins that house passengers or crew with AGE are cleaned and disinfected daily while the occupants are ill.

Other inspection items (5 findings)

Item 22

Where it was found: Pantry-Deck 11 - Lime and Coconut

Official finding: A tangled hair and a leaf were inside the strainer of the hood-type dishwash machine. This was immediately cleaned.

Official recommendation

Ensure warewashing machines, drainboards, and the compartments of sinks, basins, or other receptacles used for washing and rinsing equipment, utensils, or raw food, or laundering wiping cloths are cleaned: (1) Before use; (2) Throughout the day at a frequency necessary to prevent recontamination and accumulation of debris and to ensure the equipment performs its intended function; (3) At least every 24 hours (if used).

Item 20

Where it was found: Bar-Deck 5 - Bull and Bear Pub

Official finding: A slotted fastener was on the food splash zone of a soda gun dispenser.

Official recommendation

Use low profile, nonslotted, noncorroding, and easy-to-clean fasteners on food-contact surfaces and in splash zones. Prohibit the use of exposed slotted screws, Phillips head screws, or pop rivets in these areas.

Item 19

Where it was found: Bar-Deck 5 - Casino Royale (Non-Smoking)

Official finding: A crew member dropped the cap to a plastic soda bottle on the deck and did not clean and sanitize the cap before reapplying to the bottle. The bottle was discarded immediately.

Official recommendation

Protect food from contamination that may result from a physical, chemical, biological origin.

Item 40

Where it was found: Bar-Deck 3 - Outdoor Crew Bar

Official finding: Two dead ants were on the countertop. The area was not open for service. Pest management personnel immediately responded to the area.

Official recommendation

Remove dead or trapped insects, rodents, and other pests from control devices and the vessel at a frequency that prevents their accumulation or decomposition or the attraction of other pests.

Item 22

Where it was found: Pantry-Deck 3 - Indoor Crew Bar

Official finding: Excessive water accumulated in the bottom of the undercounter warewashing machine 1.5 inches above the strainer. The lower wash arm was partially submerged. The unit ran through two full cycles and the water remained. During the second cycle, no water was discharged from the drain line into the deck scupper. Crew immediately initiated corrective action. Additionally, in the same unit, food service equipment was loaded into the unit in a manner that did not allow the wash or sanitizing rinse sprays to effectively clean and sanitize all surfaces. Two flat trays were stacked on each other, and these two were stacked on the back of the hotel pan. Additionally, other food service equipment was on the rack.

Official recommendation

Maintain warewashing equipment in good repair and proper adjustment, including: (1) Warewashing equipment is maintained in a state of repair and condition that meets the standards of the materials, design, and construction. Ensure soiled items to be cleaned in a warewashing machine are loaded into racks, trays, or baskets or onto conveyors in a position that (1) Exposes the items to the unobstructed spray from all cycles; (2) Allows the items to drain.

Pest and insect management (1 finding)

Item 39

Where it was found: Food Service General-Pests in Food Areas

Official finding: Live pests were in the following areas: 1) Two small flies at the Deck 5 Main Galley beverage station 2) Five ants at the Deck 3 outdoor Crew Bar 3) One small fly and one large fly at the Deck 3 indoor Crew Bar 4) One small fly in the Deck 14 Viking Crown Lounge area.

Official recommendation

Effectively control the presence of insects, rodents, and other pests to minimize their presence in food areas.

Swimming pools and whirlpools (2 findings)

Item 10

Where it was found: Housekeeping-Jetted Tubs - Draining, Cleaning, and Disinfection Log

Official finding: The jetted tub in passenger stateroom # 1320 was disinfected on 27 April 2026 from 0800-0806 which did not meet the required 10-minute minimum as per company policy. Additionally, the following passenger staterooms had incorrect cleaning and disinfecting start and stop times.

  • Stateroom #1334
  • 07 March 2026 from 0850-0812
  • Stateroom #1348
  • 26 March 2026 from 0750-0715
Official recommendation

Ensure manufacturer’s operation and maintenance instructions are available to personnel who service these jetted tubs and heated jetted tubs. Retain maintenance records on the vessel for 12 months. Ensure records include: (1) Cleaning and disinfection frequency; (2) Disinfectant type, concentration, and contact time; (3) Draining frequency (only for heated jetted tubs).

Item 44

Where it was found: Recreational Water Facilities-Bather Loads

Official finding: The following recreational water facilities exceeded the posted bather load limits indicated on the safety signage at the time of the inspection:

  • Deck 11
  • Main Pool Starboard Side - posted limit of 22 bathers with approximately 40 passengers in the pool.
  • Deck 11
  • Main Pool Port Side - posted limit of 18 bathers with approximately 35 passengers in the pool.
  • Deck 11
  • Solarium Pool - posted limit of 17 bathers with approximately 40 passengers in the pool. Pool attendants were on duty at the time of the inspection.
Official recommendation

Ensure the supervisor or person responsible for RWFs operations on the vessel demonstrates to VSP, on request during inspections, knowledge of RWF operations, is able to demonstrate this knowledge by compliance with Section 6 of the VSP Environmental Public Health Standards or by responding correctly to the inspector’s questions as they relate to the specific operation, and ensure employees are properly trained to comply with Section 6 of the VSP Environmental Public Health Standards as it relates to their assigned duties.

Gastrointestinal outbreak notices

These are official CDC Vessel Sanitation Program outbreak postings for this ship, not inspection scores. CDC generally posts a voyage when 3% or more of passengers or crew report gastrointestinal illness, or when an outbreak is otherwise of public health significance.

Official outbreak notices collected for this ship

Sailing datesCausative agentCase countsSource
12/3/2006-12/10/2006 (no sail recommendation)NorovirusPassengers: 85 of 3,907. Crew: 11 of 1,399 (0.84%).CDC notice
11/26/2006-12/3/2006NorovirusPassengers: 338 of 3,823 (8.84%). Crew: 46 of 1,402 (3.28%).CDC notice

Source: CDC Vessel Sanitation Program. This page does not change the substantive content of official scores or findings.